SOTW 56 - Freestyle - Voting Thread

Sig 1



Sig 2



Sig 3



Sig 4



Sig 5



Sig 6



Sig 7



Sig 8



Sig 9



Sig 10

​

 

Why do you guys make it so hard to choose!

Many great ones, but when I scrolled down to 10, it was a win.

 

all friggin sweet sigs!

but the colours of sig 8 just won it for me!

very hard though!

 

great work everyone :thumbs:

#5 and #6 are my favourites

 

I can't choose tonight... maybe tomorrow!

 

Gotta come back to this. There's four that really stand out for me and I can't choose. It's so damn hard with the vast variety of subjects and each stand out in their own way that would rightly win if entered into a specificly themed SOTW.
Excellent job, it's never this hard to decide.

 

Voted!

 

So tough but in the end there was only one that got me.

 

u who made sig10 but i demand u give it to me!
awesome work guys!

 

Ess definitely needs sig #10.

and this is my thought process: "o hey, #2 looks nice. oo, 6 looks interesting. #10 *jaw drops*"

 

sig 2....for the face in the background

 

No wonder it'll be a landslide win for #10 but I still added my vote to this awesome piece.

 

Voted

GREAT job and WELL DONE on all the entries! One thats obviously standing out for most, but every single one is awesome *applause*

 

Sig 9 - I tend to opt for these as the random splashing and swirls of colour do little for me, I still struggle to see the relevence to the actual subject of the sig and find more often than not it distracts from the main focus of it.

Sig 3 would be an example of how it can work, but in sig 1 and sig 10 I really dont understand the backgrounds, perhaps sigs are being made for other sig makers and they realise the difficulty of producing that effect?

Not a critisism as such, all the sigs are very well made and credit to the creators.

 

@gaphugs: everybody has different view point but there should be something common in sig design. You said you didn't understand the bg in sig 10, yeah simple lines but they add to the flow of the sig: when your eye goes with the lines they arrive at the focal.

There are so many factors in a sig design: composition, colors, depth, transitions, smoothness, uniqueness, techniques, flow, lightning, text, "wow"-factor. And I really think we should vote like some other forums: vote with an ARTISTIC REASON but not vote because I like the focal she's my fav signer, etc.

 

For me it was between 3 or 6...
Why I dont know just found them appealing to my 'artistic' sense..
Finally voted.

 

Voted.

 

After much debate I went with sig 9.
Cool picture, nice depth and lighting.

 

Voted

 

Great sigs this week

#2 grabbed my attention right away :thumbs: