Sig Duel #1: Round 2: GBTG vs kaos42000

Sig Duel #1: Round 2 - Cosmic Theme

Choose which sig you like best, and feel free to comment on why you chose it.
After all constructive criticism is the best way to improve our skills!

1.


2.

​

 

Voted. I thought that the blue spectrum would be dominant in this theme.

Sig 1 - Excellent. I love the feel of an event taking place in this one. I'd have like to see the white ring around the middle of the planet so we could see more of the asteroids floating. I think i'd have darkened the right side of it behind the smaller planet/star to make it pop more.

Sig 2 - The only thing i didn't dig with the sig was the face silhouette. It's good but it feels out of place. It looks like there is some abstract city in the background. I'd like to see a little more of that.

I picked sig 1.

 

Voted.

I too thought the silhouette was out of place, plus you misspelled Duel. I went with Sig #1 also.

Great job to the both of you.

 

Voted

 

Voted for #1, I literally said "Holy shit!" when I saw it.

The only thing I didn't like about it was the text plus the white line, but the rest is perfect.

 

Both really great, but I really liked the first one because the text seemed to fit in better that #2.

Both great work! Keep it up.

 

Voted.

 

Voted.

 

voted 1

1. nice work, got your point across tastefully

2. misspelled (Damn I hate it when that happens. Worst part about it is you never notice till somebody points it out, then you wanna hide under a rock).

Aside from the typo, they were both excellent.

 

voted. very tough choice.

 

#1 awesome picture! i wish i knew if author made it by himself or just cut from someone else's work.
+ i like the surface of this big planet, it's complex and intriguing. i like the composition.
- the text doesn't fit in this place (that line too)
#2 "a girl against the universe"
+ the girl ofc., there's a lot of shapes in the background, every time i look at this i can see something new
- not very 'cosmic' imo

i haven't voted yet, it's hard choice


ok, voted!

 

Voted!

 

Voted!

 

Voted!

 

Voted

 

Voted no.1

Nice colours (much like sig 2), liking the glow off it. It also has a cosmic feel to it. Like the border a lot too. How come people don't like the line on the text? I think it finishes it off quite nice.
The only thing wrong with 2 imo was the face at the left. It's a nice sig though and the text fits it well.

 

Well sometimes I just think that some sigs would be much better without any text on it or any thing else that could distract the viewers from the rest of the signature.

But that's just my opinion.

 

Voted.

 

I think a sig should ALWAYS have text

 

voted for #1!

I actually sat here staring at the screen for 5 minutes though because I couldn't decide.

Face on the left on #2 kinda swayed me towards #1