Sig Battle: GBTG vs Irish-Sid - Guitars

Sig 1


Sig 2


~ Please comment as to why you chose a certain sig! ~

Best of luck Sid! :thumbs:

​

 

Good luck.

 

2 is great, nicely balanced and really clean and sharp, but i went with 1 for the glowing effect running up and around the guitar, really nice work. text could have been better but i like the shadow, blends it into the sig nicely

 

the colours in number one are great. but the pic of the guitar was off for me.

love the crispness of number two, it won it over for me!

great job on both.

 

Another toughie, 2 IS cleaner but I'm drawn to the flaming lightshow of 1, reminds me of the paintjob on a nice custom car or chopper.

 

Tough vote, both are very nice!

#1 has awesome effects around the guitar, but the text is weaker a little, shadow adds something to it though!

#2 is very clean, easy on the eye, great text, well placed guitar renders, a bit too many bubbles for my taste though!

Having that said, I voted for #2, but well done to both of you.

 

I'm in a bit of quite mood at the mo and 1 makes my head hurt: ruddy hangover

So I picked 2

 

Really, REALLY tough choice! Both look amazing!

 

Same here... #2 is more clean.

But awesome work!

 

I hate you guys ... seriously ... for creating so damn tough choices. It took me some time. Each sig is b-r-i-l-l-i-an-t.

I just had to go with #2 because it caught my eye immediately.

 

#1 very dynamic, not quite as clean, good use of color, good use of the shadow on the text, weak on the frame work.

#2 very clean, bubble defocus into the background very nice, text was a bit too lacking in contrast to the subjects, especially on the left end. Nice frame, not my choice of frame color with that background, imo, it became muddy.

Went with #1 mostly for the dynamic color.

 

Voted.

 

I liked the glowing effect on sig 1 thats why i ended up voting for that one.

 

I went with 1. it has vibrant colors and a nice mood.

I don't like the boubles in the second, looks like the artist is trying to get a disco groove with the colour spots.. When the guitar look more country/western.

But it's very clean and smooth around the edges.

 

voted

 

DI!!!! You're still alive and apparently not incarcerated.
Give us an update on the Jagoff neighbors plz.

 

2 Very nice sigs, not much to choose between them.

1. had the nice light effect around the guitar, but I felt the lettering was weak.
2. was sharper with nice lettering, but with a few to many bubbles for my taste.

In the end I went for 2. because I felt the lighting effect on 1. actually detracted from the guitar itself and was perhaps a bit to busy, having said that I felt 2. could have done with a few less bubbles for the same reason.

 

Sig 1. Liked the colours.

 

i voted 2 cause I liked it. I liked 1 too, but it was just a little too bright!

 

voted.

good theme, I love guitars.